Editorial score of 9.2 of 10, the composite average of the three factors above (Rooms, Service, Location). Method at our methodology page. Affiliate disclosure: booking links may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you, and never change our verdict.
Why is Four Seasons Hotel New York back among Midtown's best?
Four Seasons Hotel New York earns its place because the bones are unrepeatable. The hotel sits inside a 52-story limestone tower that I.M. Pei designed and opened in 1993, and the backlit-onyx grand lobby with its towering ceilings remains one of the most serious pieces of hotel architecture in the country. It is not a lifestyle experiment and not chasing a scene. It is a large, formal, exactingly finished five-star hotel at the corner of Midtown power, and that clarity of purpose is exactly why it matters. The building closed in 2020 and stayed dark for four years, so the November 2024 reopening had three decades of standards to live back up to.
The reopening also changed the math. Owner Ty Warner used the closure to reconfigure the tower toward suites and residences, so the hotel now runs about 219 rooms and suites rather than the 368 it once had, with most accommodations reading as junior or one-bedroom suites and a run of full-floor specialty suites above. Service travelled through the closure intact: the concierge still solves problems that would defeat a travel agent, the doormen still know the names, and turndown still comes with a handwritten note. For a client-facing business trip, a proposal or a milestone stay where you want the most composed address on 57th Street, this is the benchmark, provided you set expectations for a formal Midtown tower rather than a downtown scene.
What are the best rooms to request?
Request a high-floor one-bedroom suite and treat the square footage as the point, because after the reconfiguration this is essentially an all-suite hotel. Accommodations run from roughly 500 square feet up to full-floor specialty suites, with the Ty Warner Penthouse crowning the 52nd floor, and the Pei tower delivers ceiling height and light that few Manhattan hotels can match. Bathrooms are finished in warm marble with deep soaking tubs and separate rain showers, and the higher you climb the more Central Park and the Midtown grid open up through the windows. For a proposal or an anniversary, the corner suites on the upper floors are worth the step up in price for the double aspect alone.
One honest caveat: the reconfiguration means part of the tower is now residences and long-term rentals, and inventory can shift, so confirm you are booking a hotel suite rather than an extended-stay unit if the difference matters to you. The interiors are contemporary and composed rather than storied, so guests hunting Old New York patina will find the rooms polished and current instead. And this is among the most expensive rooms in the city, so book the highest category your budget allows and let the address do the work.
Ask for a suite facing north for Central Park light, and book The Garden for weekend brunch a day ahead, as the room fills with locals. If you are proposing, the concierge team handles flowers, champagne and a private setup, so share your timing early.
What is the dining and the bar scene like?
Dining came back as a genuine reason to book rather than a convenience. The signature restaurant is The Garden, a dramatic forest-like room set between African acacia trees overlooking the Art Deco lobby, where Executive Chef Maria Tampakis runs a Northern Italian menu at breakfast, brunch and weekday lunch. Beside it, Ty Bar is the soaring Art Deco cocktail lounge, with a serious list of Manhattans and refined small plates, plus live music on Thursday evenings that makes it one of the more grown-up rooms in Midtown for a drink. Between the two you can eat and drink very well without leaving the building, from a working lunch to a long celebratory evening.
Does it have a spa and pool?
Yes to the spa. The hotel used the closure to rebuild its wellness offer, and it unveiled an enhanced spa in 2025 alongside an updated fitness centre, aimed at both hotel guests and local members. Treatment rooms, steam facilities and a well-equipped gym are all part of the reopened wellness floor. If a lap pool is essential to your stay, confirm current pool availability with the hotel directly when you book, as the reopened configuration is still settling into its full amenity roster.
Signature amenities
In the heart of Midtown East
Midtown East · between Park and Madison Avenues
What's nearby
- Fifth Avenue shopping
Bergdorf Goodman, flagships4 min walk - Central Park
Grand Army Plaza6 min walk - Museum of Modern Art
MoMA on 53rd8 min walk - The Plaza
Central Park South7 min walk - Rockefeller Center
Shops & skating12 min walk
The tower, the lobby, the suites
Tower
Suite
Grand lobby
BathroomHow does Four Seasons New York compare with Midtown's other five-star hotels?
Against the field, Four Seasons New York is the architecture-and-service benchmark, the most formal tower on 57th Street. The St. Regis New York is the Fifth Avenue power address, built on butler service and old-world ceremony. The Peninsula New York trades on its Fifth Avenue rooftop and a classic grand-hotel feel a few blocks south. Park Hyatt New York is the quiet contemporary choice on the same 57th Street block, discreet where the Four Seasons is grand. The Four Seasons trade-off is simple: it is expensive, and the reconfiguration means you are booking into an all-suite tower rather than the larger classic hotel it once was.
| Hotel | Style | Best for | Trade-off |
|---|---|---|---|
| Four Seasons New York | Formal I.M. Pei tower | Architecture, suites, service | Premium rates; now all-suite |
| The St. Regis New York | Fifth Avenue landmark | Butler service, ceremony | Traditional, less contemporary |
| The Peninsula New York | Grand Fifth Avenue hotel | Rooftop, classic scale | Busy corner, older feel in parts |
| Park Hyatt New York | Quiet modern 57th Street | Discreet stays, spa pool | Less grand, fewer public rooms |
Frequently asked questions
Is Four Seasons Hotel New York open, and can you book it?
Yes. The hotel reopened in November 2024 after a closure that began in 2020, and it brought its full room inventory back online through early 2025. It is fully operational and taking reservations for 2026, so you can book it directly or through the usual channels.
Who designed Four Seasons Hotel New York and how tall is it?
The hotel occupies a 52-story limestone tower designed by I.M. Pei that opened in 1993. The soaring backlit-onyx grand lobby with its very high ceilings is the building's signature, and the Ty Warner Penthouse crowns the 52nd floor.
How many rooms does Four Seasons Hotel New York have now?
About 219 rooms and suites, down from 368 before the closure. Owner Ty Warner reconfigured the tower toward junior and one-bedroom suites and converted some floors to residences and long-term rentals, so most accommodations are now suites ranging from roughly 500 square feet to full-floor specialty suites.
What are the restaurants and bars at Four Seasons Hotel New York?
The Garden is the signature restaurant, a forest-like room overlooking the Art Deco lobby serving a Northern Italian menu by Executive Chef Maria Tampakis at breakfast, brunch and weekday lunch. Ty Bar is the Art Deco cocktail lounge, with live music on Thursday evenings.
Where is Four Seasons Hotel New York located?
At 57 East 57th Street in Midtown East, between Park and Madison Avenues. Fifth Avenue flagship shopping is a few minutes west, Central Park and Grand Army Plaza are a short walk north, and the Museum of Modern Art sits four blocks south.
Other luxury stays in New York
#3 · Fifth AveThe St. Regis New York
#6 · Fifth AveThe Peninsula New York
#8 · 57th St