Editorial score of 9.4 of 10, the composite average of the three factors above (Rooms, Service, Location). Method at our methodology page. Affiliate disclosure: booking links may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you, and never change our verdict.
Why is Aman New York the top hotel in New York?
Aman New York is our number one because it corners the one thing money struggles to buy in Manhattan: privacy and space at scale. The hotel occupies the upper floors of the Crown Building, the 1921 landmark on the corner of 57th Street and Fifth Avenue, and it is an all-suite house of only 83 keys. That restraint is the whole idea. Where the city's other trophy hotels chase a lobby scene, Aman keeps its public rooms hushed and its guests screened, so the experience reads more like a private residence stacked forty floors above Fifth Avenue than a hotel. A working fireplace glows in every suite, the materials run to bronze, bleached oak and Japanese stone, and the studied quiet is the point rather than a side effect.
The hardware backs the mood. The three-level Aman Spa is the most serious wellness floor in any New York hotel, and the two restaurants, Arva and Nama, are destinations rather than conveniences. Service follows the Aman doctrine: bags vanish before you reach the lift, your name is known without it feeling scripted, and the ratio of staff to guests is generous enough that nothing feels rushed. The honest counterpoint is value. At rates that start from roughly $2,800 a night, this is one of the most expensive hotels in the country, and more than one guest checks out asking whether any city hotel clears that bar. For a honeymoon, a landmark celebration or a wellness reset where you plan to stay in, it is unmatched.
What are the best suites to request?
There are no standard rooms here, only suites, so the decision is really about height and aspect. Entry Studio and One-Bedroom suites start from around 718 square feet, larger than the flagship rooms at most New York hotels, and every one has a working fireplace, a deep soaking tub and a calm palette of bronze, oak and stone. Request a high-floor suite facing north or west for the best Central Park and Fifth Avenue light, and step up to a corner or the Aman Suite if you want the double aspect and the widest skyline. The screened terraces on the higher keys are among the very few private outdoor spaces at this altitude in Midtown.
One honest caveat at this rate: several recent reviewers report that street noise and car horns can reach the suites at night, a reminder that even forty floors up you are still on the busiest corner of Fifth Avenue, so ask for a higher, interior-facing suite if you are a light sleeper. A handful of spa guests have also flagged treatments delivered by staff still in training at full price. Neither undoes the case, but at these numbers you are entitled to raise them at booking.
Book the Aman Spa and a table at Nama's omakase counter before arrival, as both fill weeks ahead. For a honeymoon, ask the team to lay the fire and draw the bath for your first evening, and request a north-facing suite for Central Park light at dusk.
What is the dining and the bar scene like?
Dining is genuinely a reason to book. Arva is Aman's Italian room, a serene indoor-outdoor dining space serving pasta, fish and meat alongside a strong breakfast and brunch. Nama draws on the group's Asian roots for washoku, the Japanese art of seasonal balance, and you can sit at the Hinoki-wood sushi counter for an omakase or in the wider dining room. Below ground, the Aman Jazz Club is a low-lit supper-club room that is one of the more atmospheric night-time spaces in Midtown, and the Garden Terrace bar handles cocktails and afternoon tea. Between them you can spend an entire evening moving through distinct rooms without leaving the building.
Does it have a spa and pool?
Yes, and it is the strongest wellness offer in the city by a clear margin. The Aman Spa runs across three levels and centres on a tranquil 65-foot indoor pool, unusually long for a Midtown hotel, alongside 10 treatment rooms and a serious fitness centre. The standout feature is the pair of private Spa Houses, each with a hammam or a wood-clad banya, a marble steam room and a private outdoor terrace with a hot bath and cold plunge. Booked for a half-day, a Spa House is effectively a private wellness apartment in the sky, and it is what separates Aman from every other spa in New York.
Signature amenities
On the corner of 57th and Fifth
Midtown · corner of 57th Street and Fifth Avenue
What's nearby
- Bergdorf Goodman
Fifth Avenue flagships2 min walk - Central Park
Grand Army Plaza4 min walk - The Plaza
Central Park South4 min walk - Museum of Modern Art
MoMA on 53rd7 min walk - Carnegie Hall
57th & Seventh9 min walk
The suites, the spa, the dining
Suite
Living room
Spa pool
ArvaHow does Aman New York compare with New York's other top hotels?
Against the field, Aman New York is the privacy-and-space benchmark, the most exclusive and most expensive address in the city. The Mark Hotel is the restaurant-led Upper East Side alternative, louder and more social, with Central Park a block away. The Carlyle trades on old-New-York romance and Bemelmans Bar rather than raw scale. The Lowell is the smallest and most discreet of the group, a townhouse-style hotel with wood-burning fireplaces. Aman's own trade-off is simply the rate: nothing else in New York costs this much, and its all-suite, stay-in model suits a retreat far better than a busy sightseeing trip.
| Hotel | Style | Best for | Trade-off |
|---|---|---|---|
| Aman New York | All-suite Fifth Avenue retreat | Privacy, space, spa | Highest rates in the city |
| The Mark Hotel | Restaurant-led Upper East Side | Dining, Central Park, scene | Busier, less private |
| The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel | Old-New-York landmark | Romance, Bemelmans Bar | Classic rather than modern |
| The Lowell | Discreet townhouse hotel | Fireplaces, quiet, intimacy | Small, no big spa or pool |
Frequently asked questions
What makes Aman New York the best hotel in New York City?
Aman New York buys the most private square footage in Manhattan. It is an all-suite hotel of just 83 keys inside the landmark Crown Building, every suite has a working fireplace, and the three-level Aman Spa with its 65-foot pool is the largest and most serious wellness floor in any New York hotel. Privacy and space, not a scene, are the product.
How many suites does Aman New York have and how big are they?
There are 83 suites and no standard rooms, starting from around 718 square feet, which is larger than the entry rooms at almost any other New York hotel. Each suite has a working fireplace, a soaking tub and a calm, Japanese-influenced palette of bronze, oak and stone.
What are the restaurants and bars at Aman New York?
The two signature restaurants are Arva, an Italian dining room, and Nama, a Japanese washoku restaurant with an intimate omakase counter. The hotel also runs a subterranean Jazz Club and a Garden Terrace bar, so you can eat and drink across several distinct rooms without leaving the building.
Does Aman New York have a spa and pool?
Yes, and it is the strongest in the city. The Aman Spa spans three levels with a tranquil 65-foot indoor pool, 10 treatment rooms, a fitness centre and two private Spa Houses, each with a hammam or banya, a steam room and an outdoor terrace with a hot bath and cold plunge.
How much does Aman New York cost and where is it?
Suites typically start from roughly $2,800 a night and rise steeply for the larger keys, making it one of the most expensive hotels in the United States. It sits in the Crown Building at 730 Fifth Avenue, on the corner of 57th Street and Fifth Avenue, a short walk from Central Park and Bergdorf Goodman.
Other luxury stays in New York
#2 · Upper East SideThe Mark Hotel
#5 · Upper East SideThe Carlyle
#11 · Upper East Side