Soho Grand Hotel

Editorial score of 8.7 of 10, the composite average of the three factors above (Rooms, Service, Location). Method at our methodology page. Affiliate disclosure: booking links may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you, and never change our verdict.

Is the Soho Grand Hotel worth booking?

It is worth booking if the Grand Bar and a true SoHo address are what you are after, and if you have costed the amenity fee honestly first. The Soho Grand opened on 4 August 1996 as the first new hotel built in SoHo in a century, and it proved to the New York luxury market that downtown could sustain a full-service house at rates Midtown had assumed as its own. The building references the neighbourhood's cast-iron industrial fabric without imitating it, David Helpern designed it and William Sofield of Studio Sofield handled the interiors, and the Grand Bar and Salon captured the neighbourhood's social life within months of opening. Nearly three decades on, the bar remains the strongest reason to stay: residents still treat it as their own, and as a guest you walk into a genuine local institution rather than a hotel lounge.

The honest counterweight is value. A mandatory amenity fee of 39.95 dollars plus tax is charged every night whether or not you touch the bikes, the Champagne or the dog park, which narrows the gap between the Soho Grand and cleaner-priced neighbours. The rooms are comfortable and characterful rather than best-in-class, there is no pool and no spa, and the Grand Bar's late-night DJ sets are a draw for some guests and a reason for others to request a higher floor. Against the Mercer two blocks north, which we score higher on all three axes, the Soho Grand's case rests on the bar, the scale for groups and a softer entry rate. Book it for those, with the true cost in view, and it earns its keep.

What are the best rooms to request?

Request a high floor and, if the budget stretches, one of the two penthouse lofts, because the upper categories are where the Soho Grand earns its rate. The 353 rooms and suites climb 17 floors, and the higher you go the more you get of the West Broadway light and the downtown rooftops rather than the street. The design keeps the original cast-iron and bottle-glass vocabulary that echoes SoHo's industrial past, and the rooms read as characterful and warm rather than minimalist. Ten suites give you more room to spread out, and the two penthouse lofts at the top are the choice for a special stay, with the volume and the outlook the standard rooms cannot match.

The honest caveat is that entry rooms are compact and the interiors, while stylish, are on the older side of the SoHo set now that newer neighbours have opened. There is no pool and no spa, only a fitness room with Peloton bikes, and the Grand Bar and Salon runs live DJs from Wednesday to Saturday into the small hours, so light sleepers should ask for a room on a higher floor away from the bar. Skip the smallest category, request height for quiet and view, and the room becomes a comfortable base for the neighbourhood rather than the reason to come.

What is the dining and the bar scene like?

The Grand Bar and Salon is the whole story and has been since 1996. It is the hotel's most significant social space and its most durable advantage: a bar that has served SoHo's creative and fashion crowd for nearly three decades, that residents use as a gathering point, and that you reach as a guest simply by taking the stairs down. Alongside it, the 24-hour Soho Diner covers the round-the-clock, all-American end of the menu, and the Club Room lounge gives you a quieter room for a drink. In the warmer months the seasonal Gilligan's terrace and The Gallery exhibition space open up. Between the bar and the diner you can eat and drink well without leaving the building, from a late-night burger to a long evening at the Grand Bar.

Does it have a spa or pool?

No, and it is worth being direct about it. The Soho Grand has a fitness room, now fitted with Peloton bikes, but there is no pool and no spa, which is standard for a boutique of this vintage in a dense downtown block. Wellness here means a workout and a walk through SoHo rather than treatment suites and a lap pool. If a spa day or a swim is part of your trip you should look elsewhere; if the draw is the bar, the address and the neighbourhood on your doorstep, the missing spa is a fair trade rather than a real gap.

Signature amenities

On SoHo's main spine at West Broadway

The building, the rooms, the Grand Bar

Exterior

Guest room

Grand Bar

Penthouse loft

How does the Soho Grand compare with other SoHo hotels?

Against the field, the Soho Grand is the original and the most social of the SoHo hotels, and the choice comes down to what you value. The Mercer two blocks north is the correct SoHo hotel for many, smaller and more discreet, scoring higher on all three axes and keeping its pricing cleaner. The Manner on Thompson Street is the newest arrival, with a rooftop that locals actually use and a fresher design. 11 Howard is the design-forward option at the neighbourhood's northern crossroads. The Soho Grand's own trade-off is the one to weigh: you get the Grand Bar, the scale for groups and a softer entry rate, but the rooms are older than the newer set and the amenity fee is non-negotiable.

Other luxury stays in New York

#10 · SoHo

The Mercer Hotel

SoHo · discreet luxury

★★★★★HFK 9.2

#35 · SoHo

The Manner

SoHo · rooftop

★★★★★HFK 8.8

#22 · SoHo

11 Howard

SoHo · design hotel

★★★★★HFK 8.7

Explore more